Skip to main content

Transplant surgeon who burned his initials on to the livers of two patients could face a longer ban after General Medical Council complained a five-month suspension was 'insufficient'

Simon Bramhall, 53, admitted using a laser to write his initials on the organs

Simon Bramhall, 53, admitted using a laser to write his initials on the organs

A transplant surgeon who burned his initials onto the livers of two unconscious patients could now have his punishment increased after the General Medical Council complained that a five-month suspension was 'insufficient'.

High Court judge Mrs Justice Collins Rice ordered a fresh Medical Practitioners Tribunal hearing into Simon Bramhall's case after considering a GMC appeal.

The judge, based in London, said a tribunal that considered the case last year did not 'put its finger on precisely what was and was not wrong' with Mr Bramhall's conduct.

Bramhall, who is in his 50s and was a transplant surgeon at University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust, was given a community order and fined £10,000 by a judge at Birmingham Crown Court in January 2018 after he admitted two counts of assault by beating.

He told police he used an argon beam machine to initial the organs to relieve operating theatre tensions following difficult and long transplant operations in 2013.

Mrs Justice Collins Rice was told that, in December 2020, a Medical Practitioners Tribunal imposed a five-month suspension on Bramhall's medical registration.

Lawyers representing the GMC said the sanction was 'insufficient to maintain public confidence' in the profession.

The judge, who published a ruling online on Tuesday after considering arguments at a High Court hearing earlier this month, allowed the GMC's appeal.

She said the case must be reconsidered by a new tribunal.

'The Medical Practitioners Tribunal did not put its finger on precisely what was and was not wrong with Mr Bramhall's conduct and sanction accordingly,' she said.

'It did not do full justice to this unique case.

'I allow this appeal on that basis.

'I am satisfied that the right way forward is to quash the sanctions determination and remit the case for a fresh determination by a differently constituted tribunal.'

Lawyers representing the GMC said a five-month suspension for Bramhall (left) was 'insufficient to maintain public confidence' in the profession

Lawyers representing the GMC said a five-month suspension for Bramhall was 'insufficient to maintain public confidence' in the profession

Mrs Justice Collins Rice heard the offences came to light when one patient had further liver surgery performed by another surgeon.

That surgeon saw and photographed 'the marks' and reported the matter to the trust's medical director.

The judge said Bramhall had admitted responsibility.

She said the facts of the case were 'highly unusual' and there was a 'profound ambivalence to be confronted' about how Bramhall and his actions should 'properly be regarded by authorities responsible'.

'On the one hand, what Mr Bramhall did was calculatedly harmless, since no physical damage beyond the 'transient and trifling' was done,' she said.

'It was also calculatedly inconsequential: the patients were not to know.

'But on the other hand, this was a criminal, non-consensual physical interference.

'It had to be sentenced as one of the most serious forms of common assault because of the multiplicity of aggravating features.

'One of his victims was certainly traumatised, writing powerfully to the sentencing court of her experience of being physically 'violated' in a sense she compared to sexual abuse or rape.'

She said Bramhall had denied 'personal gratification' and accepted 'arrogance' as one explanation.

He had also spoken of 'tension', the effects of 'pressure of work on his own judgment', and wishing to 'relieve the intensity of the theatre atmosphere'.

Popular posts from this blog

Study Abroad USA, College of Charleston, Popular Courses, Alumni

Thinking for Study Abroad USA. School of Charleston, the wonderful grounds is situated in the actual middle of a verifiable city - Charleston. Get snatched up by the wonderful and customary engineering, beautiful pathways, or look at the advanced steel and glass building which houses the School of Business. The grounds additionally gives students simple admittance to a few major tech organizations like Amazon's CreateSpace, Google, TwitPic, and so on. The school offers students nearby as well as off-grounds convenience going from completely outfitted home lobbies to memorable homes. It is prepared to offer different types of assistance and facilities like clubs, associations, sporting exercises, support administrations, etc. To put it plainly, the school grounds is rising with energy and there will never be a dull second for students at the College of Charleston. Concentrate on Abroad USA is improving and remunerating for your future. The energetic grounds likewise houses various

Best MBA Online Colleges in the USA

“Opportunities never open, instead we create them for us”. Beginning with this amazing saying, let’s unbox today’s knowledge. Love Business and marketing? Want to make a high-paid career in business administration? Well, if yes, then mate, we have got you something amazing to do!   We all imagine an effortless future with a cozy house and a laptop. Well, well! You can make this happen. Today, with this guide, we will be exploring some of the top-notch online MBA universities and institutes in the USA. Let’s get started! Why learn Online MBA from the USA? Access to More Options This online era has given a second chance to children who want to reflect on their careers while managing their hectic schedules. In this, the internet has played a very crucial in rejuvenating schools, institutes, and colleges to give the best education to students across the globe. Graduating with Less Debt Regular classes from high reputed institutes often charge heavy tuition fees. However onl

Sickening moment maskless 'Karen' COUGHS in the face of grocery store customer, then claims she doesn't have to wear a mask because she 'isn't sick'

A woman was captured on camera following a customer through a supermarket as she coughs on her after claiming she does not need a mask because she is not sick.  Video of the incident, which has garnered hundreds of thousands of views on Twitter alone, allegedly took place in a Su per Saver in Lincoln, Nebraska according to Twitter user @davenewworld_2. In it, an unidentified woman was captured dramatically coughing as she smiles saying 'Excuse me! I'm coming through' in the direction of the customer recording her. Scroll down for video An unidentified woman was captured dramatically coughing as she smiles saying 'Excuse me! I'm coming through' in the direction of a woman recording her A woman was captured on camera following a customer as she coughs on her in a supermarket without a mask on claiming she does not need one because she is not sick @chaiteabugz #karen #covid #karens #karensgonewild #karensalert #masks we were just wearing a mask at the store. ¿ o