Newspaper owner's trial over TV punch descends into farce: FIVE prosecution witnesses refuse to give evidence
The trial of Russian media magnate Alexander Lebedev got off to a farcical start yesterday when five witnesses refused to give evidence against him.
The tycoon – whose family own The Independent and London Evening Standard – pleaded not guilty to a charge of hooliganism and assault ‘based on political hatred’.
The allegation relates to a punch Lebedev, 53, threw at businessman Sergei Polonsky on a TV talk show.
Accused: Russian media magnate Alexander Lebedev (front left, pictured leaving a court hearing in Moscow) pleaded not guilty to a charge of hooliganism today Defiant: A witness told the court today that Mr Lebedev had been provoked before hitting Mr Polonsky. Five other witnesses refused to give evidence against himMr Lebedev, an outspoken critic of Russian president Vladimir Putin, owns Novaya Gazeta, Moscow’s leading investigative publication which regularly exposes state corruption.
He is the most high-profile Putin foe to be dragged through the courts this year in what many see as a Kremlin-inspired prosecution.
More... Media tycoon Alexander Lebedev facing five years in prison refused to run from potentially rigged 'hooliganism' trial in fight for 'merciful verdict' Russia's CIA spy bust 'was linked to Boston Bombing': U.S diplomat was trying to recruit Dagestan expert who travelled to terrorist’s home town when he was arrestedIf convicted, the former KGB agent faces up to five years in jail.
However, yesterday’s refusal by witnesses to attend court is a major blow to the state’s case.
Even the lawyer for Mr Polonsky said his client would not give evidence and was out of the country.
Commenting on the bizarre legal situation, Mr Lebedev’s lawyer, Genri Reznik, said: ‘I have never heard anything like this.
Show: Mr Lebedev (left) allegedly lashed out at Sergei Polonsky during a Russian TV debate in 2011 Emotions: A witness in the audience during the show told a court today that Mr Polonsky had been acting 'emotionally' before Mr Lebedev hit him
‘Will the prosecutor’s office be so weak not even to bring their witnesses? Is this how our people respect the system?’
Entering his not guilty plea on the first day of his trial, Mr Lebedev said: ‘The gist of the charges is not clear for me, particularly the point of political hatred, given that I had never met Polonsky before, and had not actually spoken to him, apart from a brief exchange.
‘My action had completely different reasons.’
Mr Lebedev has previously stated that he hit out because he feared Mr Polonsky, a 40-year-old ex-paratrooper, was poised to strike him. In another twist yesterday, a prosecution witness ended up supporting Mr Lebedev’s version of events and denied there was any political motive to the punch.
Mother-of-five Anna Slavina, a member of the studio audience at the 2011 TV talk show, said: ‘There were no political discussions.’
Viral: Footage of the punch, when Polonsky fell backwards and was knocked off his chair, went viral on the internet‘It was an educational show, not entertaining, not political. I learned a lot,’ she said.
She added that she approved of Mr Lebedev’s response to his extreme provocation.
She said that before the punch was thrown, Polonsky behaved ‘in a strongly emotional way. He was jumping around’. Asked to clarify, she said: ‘He jumped, he waved. And Lebedev tried to calm him down, just like a parent would calm down a naughty child.
‘Strange, but Polonsky’s negative emotions for some reason were targeted at Lebedev.’
Mr Polonsky’s ‘quick and wide gestures could have been considered to be dangerous,’ she said. ‘They were talking, discussing, even shouting.’
Mr Lebedev ‘controlled himself’ she said. ‘Someone else in this situation would have acted more quickly and actively...
Hooliganism: Russian President Vladimir Putin dubbed Lebedev's behaviour 'hooliganism'‘Maybe it was because of the age difference, Polonsky is young and active. Lebedev was in control of himself, he tried to answer in a polite way...’
She also confirmed that at one point Mr Polonsky threatened Mr Lebedev by saying: ‘I want to wipe your nose.’ ‘Yes he did,’ she said. ‘The presenter said – sit down, calm down. Lebedev reacted like a proper man, he controlled himself.’
The only other witness to give evidence yesterday, cameraman Denis Kolozov, said he had been filming the audience and only saw the punch later when footage of it went viral on the internet. Mr Polonsky was last night believed to be in Israel.
In March, he was released on bail by a court in Cambodia over allegations that he kidnapped and assaulted six sailors.
Commenting on the likelihood of forcing Mr Polonsky to attend the trial, judge Andrei Bakhvalov said: ‘Our bailiffs cannot search for him outside Russia, we are working only on our territory.’
The trial will resume on Thursday.